Chess2u
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

Chess2uLog in

Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz
This topic will consist of information about the bullet chess tournament that I'll be conducting. I will start out with the following 6 engines:

  • Stockfish 7
  • Komodo 10
  • Houdini 4 Pro
  • Deep Rybka 4.1
  • Gull 3
  • Fire 4

More engines will be added as the tournament progresses. Only the standard versions of each engine family can participate.

Details about the tournament:

  • Time Control - All games will be played at 1|0 time control. i.e, both the engines will receive exactly 60 seconds for a game. No extra time is added every move.
  • Hardware Used - Intel(R) Core(TM) i3 - 3130M @ 2.6 GHz with 8 GB RAM
  • Engine Parameters -

    1. Ponder - OFF
    2. Move Pruning - ON
    3. Number of processors per engine - 1
    4. Hyperthreading - OFF


  • GUI Settings-

    1. GUI - Arena 3.5.1
    2. Book - Perfect 2012 Book upto a depth of 12 half moves.
    3. TableBases - OFF
    4. Adjudication - As a loss if the evaluation is below -900 centipawns. A game will then be resigned for the weaker side if the values of the engines is lower than 9 pawns for 6 half moves. This works only, if both engines put out correct values under this threshold. If one engine gives wrong values for some reason, this does not work.


  • Elo Calculation - Both Bayeselo and EloStat will be used for the calculation of ratings.


The games can be downloaded in pgn format.

Last edited by ProCrazy on Sun Jul 03, 2016 10:44 am; edited 1 time in total

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz
The standings after 10 rounds of Round Robin is as follows:

Code:

               
   Engine                 Score          Ho         St         Fi         De         Gu         Ko    S-B
1: Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x 35.5/50 ·········· 01=0=1===0 1=1===1=01 ==1111011= =111=1==11 1011111111  772.75
2: Stockfish 7 x64        33.5/50 10=1=0===1 ·········· ==10==0=1= =111010111 0==111=111 =11111=101  755.50
3: Fire_4_x64             22.5/50 0=0===0=10 ==01==1=0= ·········· 0010=11010 1====01000 ===100==11  563.00
4: Deep Rybka 4.1 x64     20.5/50 ==0000100= =000101000 1101=00101 ·········· =1=01=0011 1=011=0=00  487.25
5: Gull 3 x64             20.0/50 =000=0==00 1==000=000 0====10111 =0=10=1100 ·········· 01100=011=  472.00
6: Komodo_10_64bit        18.0/50 0100000000 =00000=010 ===011==00 0=100=1=11 10011=100= ··········  416.50

150 games played

Tournament start: 2016.07.01, 19:40:24
Latest update: 2016.07.02, 03:03:54

Provisional bullet ratings of the engines after 50 games each as calculated by Bayeselo and EloStat are shown below:

Code:

ELOSTAT
Base rating- 3300

    Program                          Elo    +   -   Games   Score   Av.Op.  Draws

  1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x         : 3428   84  81    50    71.0 %   3272   34.0 %
  2 Stockfish 7 x64                : 3401   83  81    50    67.0 %   3278   34.0 %
  3 Fire_4_x64                     : 3276   75  75    49    45.9 %   3304   42.9 %
  4 Gull 3 x64                     : 3240   81  82    50    40.0 %   3310   32.0 %
  5 Deep Rybka 4.1 x64             : 3239   88  90    49    39.8 %   3311   22.4 %
  6 Komodo_10_64bit                : 3215   87  89    50    36.0 %   3315   24.0 %

Code:

BAYESELO
Houdini's rating is offset to 3428 so that the two rating systems are comparable.

Rank Name                     Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws
   1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x  3428   71   66    50   71%  3292   34%
   2 Stockfish 7 x64         3413   70   66    50   67%  3295   34%
   3 Fire_4_x64              3299   66   66    49   46%  3319   43%
   4 Gull 3 x64              3260   66   68    50   40%  3325   32%
   5 Deep Rybka 4.1 x64      3255   70   72    49   40%  3327   22%
   6 Komodo_10_64bit         3231   68   71    50   36%  3331   24%

Likelihood of Superiority (LOS) matrix generated by Bayeselo:

Code:

                       Ho St Fi Gu De Ko
Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x     61 99 99 99 99
Stockfish 7 x64         38    98 99 99 99
Fire_4_x64               0  1    77 79 90
Gull 3 x64               0  0 22    54 70
Deep Rybka 4.1 x64       0  0 20 45    67
Komodo_10_64bit          0  0  9 29 32  

The download link for games will be put up shortly.
EDIT : Copy of Komodo corrupted. Games re-run again in page 2.

Last edited by ProCrazy on Wed Jul 06, 2016 12:04 am; edited 1 time in total

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz
Houdini 4 Steiner than stockfish 7 and komodo 10???!!! Is à fake this man

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz
@chess-forever wrote:
Houdini 4 Steiner than stockfish 7 and komodo 10???!!! Is à fake this man


This is 1|0

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz
Code:
Hypnos 1.01 64-bit 4CPU, 15m/40+15m/40+ 2016

Hypnos 1.0.1 x64 - Komodo 10 64-bit 8.0 - 16.0 +3/=10/-11 33.33%
Hypnos 1.0.1 x64 - Stockfish 7 64 BMI2 6.5 - 17.5 +3/=7/-14 27.08%
Hypnos 1.0.1 x64 - Houdini 4 x64 B 22.5 - 1.5 +22/=1/-1 93.75%
Hypnos 1.0.1 x64 - Fire 4 x64 13.5 - 10.5 +9/=9/-6 56.25%

https://www.chess2u.com/t10570-hypnos-1-01-64-bit-4cpu-gauntlet-40-40-look
Hypnos 1.0.1 x64 - Houdini 4 x64 B 22.5 - 1.5

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz
@yanbu1 wrote:
Code:
Hypnos 1.01 64-bit 4CPU, 15m/40+15m/40+  2016

Hypnos 1.0.1 x64   - Komodo 10 64-bit        8.0 - 16.0    +3/=10/-11   33.33%
Hypnos 1.0.1 x64   - Stockfish 7 64 BMI2     6.5 - 17.5    +3/=7/-14    27.08%
Hypnos 1.0.1 x64   - Houdini 4 x64 B         22.5 - 1.5    +22/=1/-1    93.75%
Hypnos 1.0.1 x64   - Fire 4 x64              13.5 - 10.5   +9/=9/-6     56.25%

https://www.chess2u.com/t10570-hypnos-1-01-64-bit-4cpu-gauntlet-40-40-look
Hypnos 1.0.1 x64   - Houdini 4 x64 B         22.5 - 1.5


I would love to test Hypnos 1.01. Is there a download link for the engine?

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz
Standings after 20 rounds of Round Robin:

Code:

  Engine                 Score                     Ho                   St                   Fi                   Ko                   Gu                   De    S-B
1: Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x 71.5/100 ···················· 01=0=1===0==00011000 1=1===1=0111111=1111 10111111110110111111 =111=1==111==11111=1 ==1111011==10110=111  3107.5
2: Stockfish 7 x64        65.0/100 10=1=0===1==11100111 ···················· ==10==0=1=0001111011 =11111=10110=10=0101 0==111=111=100=01101 =111010111111==1111=  3024.2
3: Fire_4_x64             44.5/100 0=0===0=1000000=0000 ==01==1=0=1110000100 ···················· ===100==11000=100011 1====01000111=1=1011 0010=110100100110111  2119.0
4: Komodo_10_64bit        41.0/100 01000000001001000000 =00000=01001=01=1010 ===011==00111=011100 ···················· 10011=100==0101=1=00 0=100=1=111=10=01001  1938.0
5: Gull 3 x64             40.0/100 =000=0==000==00000=0 1==000=000=011=10010 0====10111000=0=0100 01100=011==1010=0=11 ···················· =0=10=1100111=100=10  1923.2
6: Deep Rybka 4.1 x64     38.0/100 ==0000100==01001=000 =000101000000==0000= 1101=001011011001000 1=011=0=000=01=10110 =1=01=0011000=011=01 ····················  1845.5

300 games played
Tournament start: 2016.07.01, 19:40:24
Latest update: 2016.07.02, 17:35:53

Ratings by EloStat and Bayeselo:

Code:

ELOSTAT
Base Rating - 3300
02-Jul-16 8:38:48 PM :

    Program                          Elo    +   -   Games   Score   Av.Op.  Draws

  1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x         : 3432   64  63   100    71.5 %   3272   25.0 %
  2 Stockfish 7 x64                : 3388   61  60   100    65.0 %   3281   26.0 %
  3 Fire_4_x64                     : 3270   60  60    99    44.9 %   3305   25.3 %
  4 Komodo_10_64bit                : 3246   62  63   100    41.0 %   3309   20.0 %
  5 Gull 3 x64                     : 3240   59  59   100    40.0 %   3310   28.0 %
  6 Deep Rybka 4.1 x64             : 3224   63  64    99    37.4 %   3314   20.2 %


BAYESELO

Rank Name                     Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws
   1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x  3432   52   50   100   72%  3280   25%
   2 Stockfish 7 x64         3398   51   49   100   65%  3287   26%
   3 Fire_4_x64              3279   49   50    99   45%  3311   25%
   4 Gull 3 x64              3247   48   49   100   40%  3317   28%
   5 Komodo_10_64bit         3246   50   51   100   41%  3317   20%
   6 Deep Rybka 4.1 x64      3228   50   52    99   37%  3321   20%



EDIT : Copy of Komodo corrupted. Games re-run again in page 2.

Last edited by ProCrazy on Wed Jul 06, 2016 12:05 am; edited 1 time in total

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz
Detailed results:

Code:

-----------------Deep Rybka 4.1 x64-----------------
Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 - Fire_4_x64             : 9.5/20 9-10-1 (1101=001011011001000 )  48%   -14
Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 - Gull 3 x64             : 9.5/20 7-8-5 (=1=01=0011000=011=01 )  48%   -14
Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 - Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x : 5.5/20 3-12-5 (==0000100==01001=000 )  28%  -164
Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 - Komodo_10_64bit        : 9.5/21 7-9-5 (1=011=0=000=01=101100)  45%   -35
Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 - Stockfish 7 x64        : 4.0/20 2-14-4 (=000101000000==0000= )  20%  -241
-----------------Fire_4_x64-----------------
Fire_4_x64 - Deep Rybka 4.1 x64             : 10.5/20 10-9-1 (0010=110100100110111 )  53%   +21
Fire_4_x64 - Gull 3 x64                     : 12.0/20 9-5-6 (1====01000111=1=1011 )  60%   +70
Fire_4_x64 - Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x         : 4.0/20 1-13-6 (0=0===0=1000000=0000 )  20%  -241
Fire_4_x64 - Komodo_10_64bit                : 9.0/20 6-8-6 (===100==11000=100011 )  45%   -35
Fire_4_x64 - Stockfish 7 x64                : 10.0/21 7-8-6 (==01==1=0=11100001001)  48%   -14
-----------------Gull 3 x64-----------------
Gull 3 x64 - Deep Rybka 4.1 x64             : 10.5/20 8-7-5 (=0=10=1100111=100=10 )  53%   +21
Gull 3 x64 - Fire_4_x64                     : 8.0/20 5-9-6 (0====10111000=0=0100 )  40%   -70
Gull 3 x64 - Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x         : 3.5/20 0-13-7 (=000=0==000==00000=0 )  18%  -263
Gull 3 x64 - Komodo_10_64bit                : 10.5/20 8-7-5 (01100=011==1010=0=11 )  53%   +21
Gull 3 x64 - Stockfish 7 x64                : 7.5/20 5-10-5 (1==000=000=011=10010 )  38%   -85
-----------------Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x-----------------
Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x - Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 : 14.5/20 12-3-5 (==1111011==10110=111 )  73%  +173
Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x - Fire_4_x64         : 16.0/20 13-1-6 (1=1===1=0111111=1111 )  80%  +241
Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x - Gull 3 x64         : 16.5/20 13-0-7 (=111=1==111==11111=1 )  83%  +275
Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x - Komodo_10_64bit    : 17.0/20 17-3-0 (10111111110110111111 )  85%  +301
Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x - Stockfish 7 x64    : 7.5/20 4-9-7 (01=0=1===0==00011000 )  38%   -85
-----------------Komodo_10_64bit-----------------
Komodo_10_64bit - Deep Rybka 4.1 x64        : 11.5/21 9-7-5 (0=100=1=111=10=010011)  55%   +35
Komodo_10_64bit - Fire_4_x64                : 11.0/20 8-6-6 (===011==00111=011100 )  55%   +35
Komodo_10_64bit - Gull 3 x64                : 9.5/20 7-8-5 (10011=100==0101=1=00 )  48%   -14
Komodo_10_64bit - Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x    : 3.0/20 3-17-0 (01000000001001000000 )  15%  -301
Komodo_10_64bit - Stockfish 7 x64           : 7.0/20 5-11-4 (=00000=01001=01=1010 )  35%  -108
-----------------Stockfish 7 x64-----------------
Stockfish 7 x64 - Deep Rybka 4.1 x64        : 16.0/20 14-2-4 (=111010111111==1111= )  80%  +241
Stockfish 7 x64 - Fire_4_x64                : 11.0/21 8-7-6 (==10==0=1=00011110110)  52%   +14
Stockfish 7 x64 - Gull 3 x64                : 12.5/20 10-5-5 (0==111=111=100=01101 )  63%   +92
Stockfish 7 x64 - Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x    : 12.5/20 9-4-7 (10=1=0===1==11100111 )  63%   +92
Stockfish 7 x64 - Komodo_10_64bit           : 13.0/20 11-5-4 (=11111=10110=10=0101 )  65%  +108

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz
Standings after 20 rounds (450 games) of Round Robin:

Code:

  Engine                 Score                                Ho                             St                             Fi                             Ko                             Gu                             De    S-B
1: Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x 108.5/150 ······························ 01=0=1===0==000110001==010101= 1=1===1=0111111=111111=1010=1= 1011111111011011111110=1111111 =111=1==111==11111=1101111===1 ==1111011==10110=1111=11111=11  7058.2
2: Stockfish 7 x64        100.0/150 10=1=0===1==111001110==101010= ······························ ==10==0=1=00011110110=01111110 =11111=10110=10=01010=1=01==11 0==111=111=100=01101=1=111111= =111010111111==1111=1=11111111  6792.7
3: Fire_4_x64             68.5/150  0=0===0=1000000=000000=0101=0= ==01==1=0=11100001001=10000001 ······························ ===100==11000=100011=100=01011 1====01000111=1=10111==1==1=== 0010=110100100110111=10==10110  4857.2
4: Komodo_10_64bit        61.0/150  0100000000100100000001=0000000 =00000=01001=01=10101=0=10==00 ===011==00111=011100=011=10100 ······························ 10011=100==0101=1=0010==0=0=0= 0=100=1=111=10=01001111010=1=0  4325.7
5: Gull 3 x64             59.0/150  =000=0==000==00000=0010000===0 1==000=000=011=10010=0=000000= 0====10111000=0=01000==0==0=== 01100=011==1010=0=1101==1=1=1= ······························ =0=10=1100111=100=100001==1110  4197.2
6: Deep Rybka 4.1 x64     53.0/150  ==0000100==01001=0000=00000=00 =000101000000==0000=0=00000000 1101=001011011001000=01==01001 1=011=0=000=01=10110000101=0=1 =1=01=0011000=011=011110==0001 ······························  3793.2

450 games played
Tournament start: 2016.07.01, 19:40:24
Latest update: 2016.07.03, 17:26:45

Rating calculation by EloStat and Bayeselo:

Code:

ELOSTAT
Base Rating - 3300
03-Jul-16 5:30:34 PM :

    Program                          Elo    +   -   Games   Score   Av.Op.  Draws

  1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x         : 3437   53  52   150    72.3 %   3271   24.7 %
  2 Stockfish 7 x64                : 3399   51  50   150    66.7 %   3278   25.3 %
  3 Fire_4_x64                     : 3276   48  48   149    46.0 %   3304   27.5 %
  4 Komodo_10_64bit                : 3244   50  50   150    40.7 %   3309   22.7 %
  5 Gull 3 x64                     : 3236   46  47   150    39.3 %   3311   32.0 %
  6 Deep Rybka 4.1 x64             : 3208   52  52   149    34.9 %   3317   20.1 %


BAYESELO

Rank Name                    Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws
  1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x  3437  43  41  150  72%  3276  25%
  2 Stockfish 7 x64        3406  42  41  150  67%  3282  25%
  3 Fire_4_x64              3281  40  41  149  46%  3308  28%
  4 Komodo_10_64bit        3243  41  42  150  41%  3315  23%
  5 Gull 3 x64              3241  39  40  150  39%  3315  32%
  6 Deep Rybka 4.1 x64      3209  42  43  149  35%  3322  20%


Last edited by ProCrazy on Sun Jul 03, 2016 1:08 pm; edited 1 time in total

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz
Detailed Results after 450 games:

Code:

-----------------Deep Rybka 4.1 x64-----------------
Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 - Fire_4_x64            : 14.0/30 12-14-4 (1101=001011011001000=01==01001)  47%  -21
Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 - Gull 3 x64            : 14.5/30 11-12-7 (=1=01=0011000=011=011110==0001)  48%  -14
Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 - Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x : 6.5/30 3-20-7 (==0000100==01001=0000=00000=00)  22%  -220
Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 - Komodo_10_64bit        : 13.5/30 10-13-7 (1=011=0=000=01=10110000101=0=1)  45%  -35
Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 - Stockfish 7 x64        : 4.5/30 2-23-5 (=000101000000==0000=0=00000000)  15%  -301
-----------------Fire_4_x64-----------------
Fire_4_x64 - Deep Rybka 4.1 x64            : 16.0/30 14-12-4 (0010=110100100110111=10==10110)  53%  +21
Fire_4_x64 - Gull 3 x64                    : 18.5/30 12-5-13 (1====01000111=1=10111==1==1===)  62%  +85
Fire_4_x64 - Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x        : 7.5/30 3-18-9 (0=0===0=1000000=000000=0101=0=)  25%  -191
Fire_4_x64 - Komodo_10_64bit                : 14.0/30 10-12-8 (===100==11000=100011=100=01011)  47%  -21
Fire_4_x64 - Stockfish 7 x64                : 12.5/30 9-14-7 (==01==1=0=11100001001=10000001)  42%  -56
-----------------Gull 3 x64-----------------
Gull 3 x64 - Deep Rybka 4.1 x64            : 15.5/30 12-11-7 (=0=10=1100111=100=100001==1110)  52%  +14
Gull 3 x64 - Fire_4_x64                    : 11.5/30 5-12-13 (0====10111000=0=01000==0==0===)  38%  -85
Gull 3 x64 - Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x        : 6.0/30 1-19-10 (=000=0==000==00000=0010000===0)  20%  -241
Gull 3 x64 - Komodo_10_64bit                : 17.0/30 12-8-10 (01100=011==1010=0=1101==1=1=1=)  57%  +49
Gull 3 x64 - Stockfish 7 x64                : 9.0/30 5-17-8 (1==000=000=011=10010=0=000000=)  30%  -147
-----------------Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x-----------------
Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x - Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 : 23.5/30 20-3-7 (==1111011==10110=1111=11111=11)  78%  +220
Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x - Fire_4_x64        : 22.5/30 18-3-9 (1=1===1=0111111=111111=1010=1=)  75%  +191
Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x - Gull 3 x64        : 24.0/30 19-1-10 (=111=1==111==11111=1101111===1)  80%  +241
Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x - Komodo_10_64bit    : 25.5/30 25-4-1 (1011111111011011111110=1111111)  85%  +301
Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x - Stockfish 7 x64    : 13.0/30 8-12-10 (01=0=1===0==000110001==010101=)  43%  -49
-----------------Komodo_10_64bit-----------------
Komodo_10_64bit - Deep Rybka 4.1 x64        : 16.5/30 13-10-7 (0=100=1=111=10=01001111010=1=0)  55%  +35
Komodo_10_64bit - Fire_4_x64                : 16.0/30 12-10-8 (===011==00111=011100=011=10100)  53%  +21
Komodo_10_64bit - Gull 3 x64                : 13.0/30 8-12-10 (10011=100==0101=1=0010==0=0=0=)  43%  -49
Komodo_10_64bit - Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x    : 4.5/30 4-25-1 (0100000000100100000001=0000000)  15%  -301
Komodo_10_64bit - Stockfish 7 x64          : 11.0/30 7-15-8 (=00000=01001=01=10101=0=10==00)  37%  -92
-----------------Stockfish 7 x64-----------------
Stockfish 7 x64 - Deep Rybka 4.1 x64        : 25.5/30 23-2-5 (=111010111111==1111=1=11111111)  85%  +301
Stockfish 7 x64 - Fire_4_x64                : 17.5/30 14-9-7 (==10==0=1=00011110110=01111110)  58%  +56
Stockfish 7 x64 - Gull 3 x64                : 21.0/30 17-5-8 (0==111=111=100=01101=1=111111=)  70%  +147
Stockfish 7 x64 - Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x    : 17.0/30 12-8-10 (10=1=0===1==111001110==101010=)  57%  +49
Stockfish 7 x64 - Komodo_10_64bit          : 19.0/30 15-7-8 (=11111=10110=10=01010=1=01==11)  63%  +92

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz
UPDATE: Equinox 3.30 64-bit will now participate in the games. It currently stands 5th in the CCRL 40/4 rating list.

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz
Game format changed from Round Robin to One on One.

First Pairing: Houdini-4-Pro (vs) Equinox 3.30
100 games

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz

Code:

   Engine                             Score                                                                                                                                    
                                                           
1: Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x           64.0/100
2: Equinox 3.30-x64                 36.0/100

100 games played

Code:

-----------------Equinox 3.30-x64-----------------
Equinox 3.30-x64 - Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x   : 36.0/100 13-41-46 (0====1=01010=1===0==0=000100==0====0==0=00=10000==0010====01==00==00=00000=0==1==11=1=0=000==010===0)  36%  -100
-----------------Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x-----------------
Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x - Equinox 3.30-x64   : 64.0/100 41-13-46 (1====0=10101=0===1==1=111011==1====1==1=11=01111==1101====10==11==11=11111=1==0==00=0=1=111==101===1)  64%  +100

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz
Next Pairing:

Fire_4_x64 vs Komodo_10_64bit

100 games

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz

Code:

   Engine                Score    
                                                                                               
1: Komodo_10_64bit       51.5/100
2: Fire_4_x64            48.5/100

-----------------Fire_4_x64-----------------
Fire_4_x64 - Komodo_10_64bit : 48.5/100 35-38-27 (===100==11000=100011=100=010110110==01=1==0=001=000=1=1==11101==01=000=1010010=110=10111=010100010=1)  49%    -7
-----------------Komodo_10_64bit-----------------
Komodo_10_64bit - Fire_4_x64 : 51.5/100 38-35-27 (===011==00111=011100=011=101001001==10=0==1=110=111=0=0==00010==10=111=0101101=001=01000=101011101=0)  52%   +14


EDIT : Copy of Komodo corrupted. Games re-run again in page 2.

Last edited by ProCrazy on Wed Jul 06, 2016 12:06 am; edited 2 times in total

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz
Ratings after 771 games:

Code:

ELOSTAT:
Base Rating - 3300
04-Jul-16 10:24:54 PM :

    Program                          Elo    +   -   Games   Score   Av.Op.  Draws

  1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x         : 3424   36  36   255    69.2 %   3283   33.3 %
  2 Stockfish 7 x64                : 3404   46  45   184    67.4 %   3278   25.0 %
  3 Equinox 3.30-x64               : 3307   35  35   236    46.0 %   3335   36.9 %
  4 Fire_4_x64                     : 3261   36  36   251    46.0 %   3288   29.1 %
  5 Komodo_10_64bit                : 3250   38  38   252    44.0 %   3291   22.2 %
  6 Gull 3 x64                     : 3242   40  41   182    40.9 %   3305   36.8 %
  7 Deep Rybka 4.1 x64             : 3194   47  47   182    33.5 %   3313   20.9 %

Code:


BAYESELO:

Rank Name                     Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws
   1 Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x  3424   32   31   255   69%  3292   33%
   2 Stockfish 7 x64         3414   39   38   184   67%  3284   25%
   3 Equinox 3.30-x64        3317   32   32   236   46%  3340   37%
   4 Fire_4_x64              3267   32   32   251   46%  3295   29%
   5 Komodo_10_64bit         3253   32   33   252   44%  3299   22%
   6 Gull 3 x64              3250   36   37   182   41%  3312   37%
   7 Deep Rybka 4.1 x64      3198   39   40   182   34%  3321   21%

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz
Detailed Results:

Code:

-----------------Deep Rybka 4.1 x64-----------------
Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 - Equinox 3.30-x64       : 7.0/27 4-17-6 (0==1=00=1=000000000001=0010                                                                         )  26%  -182
Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 - Fire_4_x64             : 14.5/31 12-14-5 (1101=001011011001000=01==01001=                                                                     )  47%   -21
Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 - Gull 3 x64             : 15.0/31 11-12-8 (=1=01=0011000=011=011110==0001=                                                                     )  48%   -14
Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 - Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x : 6.5/31 3-21-7 (==0000100==01001=0000=00000=000                                                                     )  21%  -230
Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 - Komodo_10_64bit        : 14.5/32 11-14-7 (1=011=0=000=01=10110000101=0=110                                                                    )  45%   -35
Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 - Stockfish 7 x64        : 4.5/31 2-24-5 (=000101000000==0000=0=000000000                                                                     )  15%  -301
-----------------Equinox 3.30-x64-----------------
Equinox 3.30-x64 - Deep Rybka 4.1 x64       : 20.0/27 17-4-6 (1==0=11=0=111111111110=1101                                                                         )  74%  +182
Equinox 3.30-x64 - Fire_4_x64               : 16.5/27 11-5-11 (1=0=0101=11=1==0101==1=1=1=                                                                         )  61%   +78
Equinox 3.30-x64 - Gull 3 x64               : 13.5/27 6-6-15 (=1=1==00011===00=====1=1=0=                                                                         )  50%    ±0
Equinox 3.30-x64 - Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x   : 36.0/100 13-41-46 (0====1=01010=1===0==0=000100==0====0==0=00=10000==0010====01==00==00=00000=0==1==11=1=0=000==010===0)  36%  -100
Equinox 3.30-x64 - Komodo_10_64bit          : 14.5/27 13-11-3 (1011110010=010001011101=10=                                                                         )  54%   +28
Equinox 3.30-x64 - Stockfish 7 x64          : 8.0/28 5-17-6 (0000000000110110=000==00==1=                                                                        )  29%  -156
-----------------Fire_4_x64-----------------
Fire_4_x64 - Deep Rybka 4.1 x64             : 16.5/31 14-12-5 (0010=110100100110111=10==10110=                                                                     )  53%   +21
Fire_4_x64 - Equinox 3.30-x64               : 10.5/27 5-11-11 (0=1=1010=00=0==1010==0=0=0=                                                                         )  39%   -78
Fire_4_x64 - Gull 3 x64                     : 19.0/31 12-5-14 (1====01000111=1=10111==1==1====                                                                     )  61%   +78
Fire_4_x64 - Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x         : 7.5/31 3-19-9 (0=0===0=1000000=000000=0101=0=0                                                                     )  24%  -200
Fire_4_x64 - Komodo_10_64bit                : 48.5/100 35-38-27 (===100==11000=100011=100=010110110==01=1==0=001=000=1=1==11101==01=000=1010010=110=10111=010100010=1)  49%    -7
Fire_4_x64 - Stockfish 7 x64                : 13.5/32 10-15-7 (==01==1=0=11100001001=1000000110                                                                    )  42%   -56
-----------------Gull 3 x64-----------------
Gull 3 x64 - Deep Rybka 4.1 x64             : 16.0/31 12-11-8 (=0=10=1100111=100=100001==1110=                                                                     )  52%   +14
Gull 3 x64 - Equinox 3.30-x64               : 13.5/27 6-6-15 (=0=0==11100===11=====0=0=1=                                                                         )  50%    ±0
Gull 3 x64 - Fire_4_x64                     : 12.0/31 5-12-14 (0====10111000=0=01000==0==0====                                                                     )  39%   -78
Gull 3 x64 - Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x         : 6.5/31 1-19-11 (=000=0==000==00000=0010000===0=                                                                     )  21%  -230
Gull 3 x64 - Komodo_10_64bit                : 17.0/31 12-9-10 (01100=011==1010=0=1101==1=1=1=0                                                                     )  55%   +35
Gull 3 x64 - Stockfish 7 x64                : 9.5/31 5-17-9 (1==000=000=011=10010=0=000000==                                                                     )  31%  -139
-----------------Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x-----------------
Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x - Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 : 24.5/31 21-3-7 (==1111011==10110=1111=11111=111                                                                     )  79%  +230
Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x - Equinox 3.30-x64   : 64.0/100 41-13-46 (1====0=10101=0===1==1=111011==1====1==1=11=01111==1101====10==11==11=11111=1==0==00=0=1=111==101===1)  64%  +100
Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x - Fire_4_x64         : 23.5/31 19-3-9 (1=1===1=0111111=111111=1010=1=1                                                                     )  76%  +200
Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x - Gull 3 x64         : 24.5/31 19-1-11 (=111=1==111==11111=1101111===1=                                                                     )  79%  +230
Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x - Komodo_10_64bit    : 26.5/31 26-4-1 (1011111111011011111110=11111111                                                                     )  85%  +301
Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x - Stockfish 7 x64    : 13.5/31 8-12-11 (01=0=1===0==000110001==010101==                                                                     )  44%   -42
-----------------Komodo_10_64bit-----------------
Komodo_10_64bit - Deep Rybka 4.1 x64        : 17.5/32 14-11-7 (0=100=1=111=10=01001111010=1=001                                                                    )  55%   +35
Komodo_10_64bit - Equinox 3.30-x64          : 12.5/27 11-13-3 (0100001101=101110100010=01=                                                                         )  46%   -28
Komodo_10_64bit - Fire_4_x64                : 51.5/100 38-35-27 (===011==00111=011100=011=101001001==10=0==1=110=111=0=0==00010==10=111=0101101=001=01000=101011101=0)  52%   +14
Komodo_10_64bit - Gull 3 x64                : 14.0/31 9-12-10 (10011=100==0101=1=0010==0=0=0=1                                                                     )  45%   -35
Komodo_10_64bit - Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x    : 4.5/31 4-26-1 (0100000000100100000001=00000000                                                                     )  15%  -301
Komodo_10_64bit - Stockfish 7 x64           : 11.0/31 7-16-8 (=00000=01001=01=10101=0=10==000                                                                     )  35%  -108
-----------------Stockfish 7 x64-----------------
Stockfish 7 x64 - Deep Rybka 4.1 x64        : 26.5/31 24-2-5 (=111010111111==1111=1=111111111                                                                     )  85%  +301
Stockfish 7 x64 - Equinox 3.30-x64          : 20.0/28 17-5-6 (1111111111001001=111==11==0=                                                                        )  71%  +156
Stockfish 7 x64 - Fire_4_x64                : 18.5/32 15-10-7 (==10==0=1=00011110110=0111111001                                                                    )  58%   +56
Stockfish 7 x64 - Gull 3 x64                : 21.5/31 17-5-9 (0==111=111=100=01101=1=111111==                                                                     )  69%  +139
Stockfish 7 x64 - Houdini_4_Pro_x64A-v1x    : 17.5/31 12-8-11 (10=1=0===1==111001110==101010==                                                                     )  56%   +42
Stockfish 7 x64 - Komodo_10_64bit           : 20.0/31 16-7-8 (=11111=10110=10=01010=1=01==111                                                                     )  65%  +108

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz
Next Pairing:

Stockfish 7 vs Gull 3

100 games

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz
Results - Stockfish 7 vs Gull 3

Code:

   Engine                  Score
                                                                                                    
1: Stockfish 7 x64         71.5/100
2: Gull 3 x64              28.5/100

-----------------Gull 3 x64-----------------
Gull 3 x64 - Stockfish 7 x64 : 28.5/100 11-54-35 (1==000=000=011=10010=0=000000==1=10000=0100000=0=0===0000=0=00=000001==0=0=0===0===000001100=====0=0)  29%  -156
-----------------Stockfish 7 x64-----------------
Stockfish 7 x64 - Gull 3 x64 : 71.5/100 54-11-35 (0==111=111=100=01101=1=111111==0=01111=1011111=1=1===1111=1=11=111110==1=1=1===1===111110011=====1=1)  72%  +164



Last edited by ProCrazy on Tue Jul 05, 2016 7:49 am; edited 1 time in total

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz
Next Pairing:

Komodo 10 vs Deep Rybka 4.1

100 games

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz

Code:

   Engine                    Score
                                                                                                    
1: Komodo_10_64bit           54.5/100
2: Deep Rybka 4.1 x64        45.5/100

-----------------Deep Rybka 4.1 x64-----------------
Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 - Komodo_10_64bit : 45.5/100 32-41-27 (1=011=0=000=01=10110000101=0=11011=0==011001001=0=110=0101=0111==0=10=1=1=01100100==10=0010=0=00=00=)  46%   -28
-----------------Komodo_10_64bit-----------------
Komodo_10_64bit - Deep Rybka 4.1 x64 : 54.5/100 41-32-27 (0=100=1=111=10=01001111010=1=00100=1==100110110=1=001=1010=1000==1=01=0=0=10011011==01=1101=1=11=11=)  55%   +35


EDIT : Copy of Komodo corrupted. Games re-run again in page 2.

Last edited by ProCrazy on Wed Jul 06, 2016 12:06 am; edited 1 time in total

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz
Next Pairing:

Equinox 3.30 vs Fire 4

100 games

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz

Code:

   Engine                     Score  
                                                                                                  
1: Equinox 3.30-x64           56.5/100
2: Fire_4_x64                 43.5/100

-----------------Equinox 3.30-x64-----------------
Equinox 3.30-x64 - Fire_4_x64               : 56.5/100 36-23-41 (1=0=0101=11=1==0101==1=1=1===0001=====1010=1==000==1101===11=11==11001=1==0=101011=1=11====11=00=001)  57%   +49
-----------------Fire_4_x64-----------------
Fire_4_x64 - Equinox 3.30-x64               : 43.5/100 23-36-41 (0=1=1010=00=0==1010==0=0=0===1110=====0101=0==111==0010===00=00==00110=0==1=010100=0=00====00=11=110)  44%   -42

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz
Next Pairing:

Houdini 4 Pro vs Komodo 10

100 games

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz
Is not true this rating list!!! Houdini over komodo 10!!!?

descriptionCrazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute) EmptyRe: Crazy Engines' Bullet Rating List (1 minute)

more_horiz
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum