Chess2u
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

Chess2uLog in

Stockfish and Clones Matches

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
Mars 3.34 x64 vs. Beluga 141221 x64 - 500R 15S+50ms

Code:

   Engine            Score            Be         Ma    S-B
1: Beluga 141221 x64 354.5/500 ·········· 260-51-189  51579.
2: Mars 3.34 x64     145.5/500 51-260-189 ··········  51579.

500 games played / Tournament finished
Name of the tournament: Mars 3.34 x64 vs. Beluga 141221 x64 - 500R 15S+50ms
Level: Blitz 0:15/0.5
Hardware: AMD Phenom(tm) IIX4 945 Processor with 6.0 GB Memory
Operating system: Linux 3.17.4-pclos1 64bit

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
Stockfish 14122811 vs. Orka 141228, Shark 141228 - Gauntlet 200R, 15S+50ms

Code:

   # PLAYER                    :  RATING    POINTS  PLAYED    (%)
   1 Orka 141228 x64           :   19.45     116.0     200   58.0%
   2 Shark 141228 x64          :   17.66     115.5     200   57.8%
   3 Stockfish 14122811 x64    :  -37.11     168.5     400   42.1%

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
SF Marco 141228 vs. Stockfish 14122811, Beluga 141228 - 200R 15S+50ms

Code:

   # PLAYER                    :  RATING    POINTS  PLAYED    (%)
   1 Beluga 141228 x64         :   32.34     227.5     400   56.9%
   2 SF Marco 141228 x64       :  -12.93     189.0     400   47.2%
   3 Stockfish 14122811 x64    :  -19.40     183.5     400   45.9%

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
Stockfish 14122819 vs. SF Marco 141228, Beluga 141228, Shark 14122819, Orka 14122819 - Gauntlet 500 Rounds, 15S+50ms

Code:

   # PLAYER                    :  RATING    POINTS  PLAYED    (%)
   1 Shark 14122819 x64        :   17.32     275.0     500   55.0%
   2 Orka 14122819 x64         :   13.07     272.0     500   54.4%
   3 Beluga 141228 x64         :    5.31     266.5     500   53.3%
   4 SF Marco 141228 x64       :  -17.85     250.0     500   50.0%
   5 Stockfish 14122819 x64    :  -17.85     936.5    2000   46.8%

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
Orka 141230 x64 vs. Komodo 8 x64 - 500R 15S+50ms

Code:

   Engine          Score            Or         Ko    S-B
1: Orka 141230 x64 342.5/500 ·········· 246-61-193  53943.
2: Komodo 8 x64    157.5/500 61-246-193 ··········  53943.

500 games played / Tournament finished
Name of the tournament: Orka 141230 x64 vs. Komodo 8 x64 - 500R 15S+50ms
Level: Blitz 0:15/0.5
Hardware: AMD Phenom(tm) IIX4 945 Processor with 6.0 GB Memory
Operating system: Linux 3.17.4-pclos1 64bit

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
Houdini 4 Pro x64 vs. Beluga 141228 x64 - 100R 5M3S

Code:

   Engine            Score        Be      Ho    S-B
1: Beluga 141228 x64 68.5/100 ······· 43-6-51  2157.7
2: Houdini 4 Pro x64 31.5/100 6-43-51 ·······  2157.7

100 games played / Tournament finished
Name of the tournament: Houdini 4 Pro x64 vs. Beluga 141228 x64 - 100R 5M3S
Level: Blitz 5/3
Hardware: AMD Phenom(tm) IIX4 945 Processor with 6.0 GB Memory
Operating system: Linux 3.17.4-pclos1 64bit

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
Sugar 3.0b vs. Stockfish 15010221, Orka 150102, Houdini 4, Komodo 8 - Gauntlet 200R 15S+15ms

Code:

   # PLAYER                    :  RATING    POINTS  PLAYED    (%)
   1 Orka 150102 x64           :   97.83     136.0     200   68.0%
   2 Stockfish 15010221 x64    :   45.97     122.5     200   61.2%
   3 Houdini 4 Pro x64         :   -9.69     107.0     200   53.5%
   4 Sugar 3.0b x64            :  -34.26     353.0     800   44.1%
   5 Komodo 8 x64              :  -99.86      81.5     200   40.8%

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
SF Marco 150103 vs. Stockfish 15010309, Beluga 150103, Shark 150103, Orka 150103 - 500R 15S+50ms

Code:

   # PLAYER                    :  RATING    POINTS  PLAYED    (%)
   1 Shark 150103 x64          :   26.77     291.0     500   58.2%
   2 Beluga 150103 x64         :   21.02     287.0     500   57.4%
   3 Orka 150103 x64           :   19.59     286.0     500   57.2%
   4 SF Marco 150103 x64       :  -31.24     889.5    2000   44.5%
   5 Stockfish 15010309 x64    :  -36.14     246.5     500   49.3%

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
Orka 15010322 vs. Rybka 4.1, Shredder 12, Disco Check 5.2.1 - Gauntlet 500R 15S+5ms

Code:

   # PLAYER                   :  RATING    POINTS  PLAYED    (%)
   1 Orka 15010322 x64        :  300.77    1336.0    1500   89.1%
   2 Rybka 4.1 x64            :   53.42      98.0     500   19.6%
   3 Shredder 12 x64          : -102.55      45.5     500    9.1%
   4 Disco Check 5.2.1 x64    : -251.65      20.5     500    4.1%

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
Komodo 8 x64 vs. Shark 15010322 x64 - 500R, 5 Minutes + 3 Seconds

Code:

  Engine             Score          Sh       Ko    S-B
1: Shark 15010322 x64 148.0/200 ········ 101-5-94  7696.0
2: Komodo 8 x64       52.0/200  5-101-94 ········  7696.0

200 games played / Tournament finished
Name of the tournament: Komodo 8 x64 vs. Shark 15010322 x64 - 200R 5M3S
Level: Blitz 5/3
Hardware: AMD Phenom(tm) IIX4 945 Processor with 6.0 GB Memory
Operating system: Linux 3.17.4-pclos1 64bit

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
Stockfish 15010523 x64 vs. Orka 150105 x64 - 200R, 5 Minutes + 3 Seconds

Code:

   Engine                 Score           Or        St    S-B
1: Orka 150105 x64        106.0/200 ········· 24-12-164  9964.0
2: Stockfish 15010523 x64 94.0/200  12-24-164 ·········  9964.0

200 games played / Tournament finished
Name of the tournament: Stockfish 15010523 x64 vs. Orka 150105 x64 - 200R 3M+3S
Level: Blitz 5/3
Hardware: AMD Phenom(tm) IIX4 945 Processor with 6.0 GB Memory
Operating system: Linux 3.17.4-pclos1 64bit

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
Stockfish 030115 IPx x64 vs. Orka 150105 x64 - 200R, 5 Minutes + 3 Seconds

Code:

   Engine                   Score           Or        St    S-B
1: Orka 150107 x64          108.0/200 ········· 27-11-162  9936.0
2: Stockfish 030115 IPx x64 92.0/200  11-27-162 ·········  9936.0

200 games played / Tournament finished
Name of the tournament: Stockfish 030115 IPx x64 vs. Orka 150105 x64 - 200R 5M+3S
Level: Blitz 5/3
Hardware: AMD Phenom(tm) IIX4 945 Processor with 6.0 GB Memory
Operating system: Linux 3.17.4-pclos1 64bi

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
@drj4759 wrote:
Stockfish 030115 IPx x64 vs. Orka 150105 x64 - 200R, 5 Minutes + 3 Seconds

Code:

   Engine                   Score           Or        St    S-B
1: Orka 150107 x64          108.0/200 ········· 27-11-162  9936.0
2: Stockfish 030115 IPx x64 92.0/200  11-27-162 ·········  9936.0

200 games played / Tournament finished
Name of the tournament: Stockfish 030115 IPx x64 vs. Orka 150105 x64 - 200R 5M+3S
Level: Blitz 5/3
Hardware: AMD Phenom(tm) IIX4 945 Processor with 6.0 GB Memory
Operating system: Linux 3.17.4-pclos1 64bi



Hi

Can you tell us what are the differences between Stockfish and these clones ? Are they just Stockfish with parameter tweaks ?

Thanks

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
You may read the comments from this link .

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
@Tomfl wrote:
@drj4759 wrote:
Stockfish 030115 IPx x64 vs. Orka 150105 x64 - 200R, 5 Minutes + 3 Seconds

Code:

   Engine                   Score           Or        St    S-B
1: Orka 150107 x64          108.0/200 ········· 27-11-162  9936.0
2: Stockfish 030115 IPx x64 92.0/200  11-27-162 ·········  9936.0

200 games played / Tournament finished
Name of the tournament: Stockfish 030115 IPx x64 vs. Orka 150105 x64 - 200R 5M+3S
Level: Blitz 5/3
Hardware: AMD Phenom(tm) IIX4 945 Processor with 6.0 GB Memory
Operating system: Linux 3.17.4-pclos1 64bi



Hi

Can you tell us what are the differences between Stockfish and these clones ? Are they just Stockfish with parameter tweaks ?

Thanks

+1

Same question here... cool

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
@drj4759 wrote:
You may read the comments from this link .


Ok thank you

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
Stockfish 15010709 x64 vs. Orka 150107 x64 - 1000R 15S+50ms

Code:

   Engine                 Score             Or         St    S-B
1: Orka 150107 x64        538.0/1000 ·········· 171-95-734  248556
2: Stockfish 15010709 x64 462.0/1000 95-171-734 ··········  248556

1000 games played / Tournament finished
Name of the tournament: Stockfish 15010709 x64 vs. Orka 150107 x64 - 500R 15S+50ms
Site/ Country: CYBIRD-PC2, United States
Level: Blitz 0:15/0.5
Hardware: AMD A8-5600K APU with Radeon(tm) HD Graphics, 8GB memory
Operating system: Linux 3.17.4-pclos1 64bit

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
Mars 3.5 x64 vs. Shark 150107 x64 - 1000R 15S+50ms

Code:

   Engine           Score              Sh          Ma    S-B
1: Shark 150107 x64 723.0/1000 ··········· 548-102-350  200271
2: Mars 3.35 x64    277.0/1000 102-548-350 ···········  200271

1000 games played / Tournament finished
Name of the tournament: Mars 3.35 x64 v. Shark 150107 x64 - 1000R 15S+50ms
Level: Blitz 0:15/0.5
Hardware: AMD Phenom(tm) IIX4 945 Processor with 6.0 GB Memory
Operating system: Linux 3.17.4-pclos1 64bit

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
SF 221212 MZ x64 vs. Beluga 150110 x64 - 300R 12S+300ms

Code:

   Engine            Score           Be        SF    S-B
1: Beluga 150110 x64 156.5/300 ········· 50-37-213  22457.
2: SF 221214 MZ x64  143.5/300 37-50-213 ·········  22457.

300 games played / Tournament finished
Name of the tournament: SF 221214 MZ x64 vs. Beluga 150110 x64 - 300R 12S+300ms
Level: Blitz 0:12/0.3
Hardware: AMD Phenom(tm) IIX4 945 Processor with 6.0 GB Memory
Operating system: Linux 3.17.4-pclos1 64bit

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
Stockfish 15010709 x64 vs. Beluga 150110 x64 - 1000R 15S+50ms

Code:

   Engine                 Score             Be         St    S-B
1: Beluga 150110 x64      536.5/1000 ·········· 165-92-743  248667
2: Stockfish 15010709 x64 463.5/1000 92-165-743 ··········  248667

1000 games played / Tournament finished
Name of the tournament: Stockfish 15010709 x64 vs. Beluga 150110 x64 - 1000R 15S+50ms
Level: Blitz 0:15/0.5
Hardware: AMD Phenom(tm) IIX4 945 Processor with 6.0 GB Memory
Operating system: Linux 3.17.4-pclos1 64bit

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
mediafire.com download/ia8awrpwdxi9c71/Beluga+150110.zip

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
Stockfish 15011122 x64 vs. Orka 150111 x64 - 500R 15S+50ms

Code:

   Engine                 Score           Or        St    S-B
1: Orka 150111 x64        273.5/500 ········· 89-42-369  61947.
2: Stockfish 15011122 x64 226.5/500 42-89-369 ·········  61947.

500 games played / Tournament finished
Name of the tournament: Stockfish 15011122 x64 vs. Orka 150111 x64 - 300R 15S+50ms
Level: Blitz 0:15/0.5
Hardware: AMD A8-5600K APU with Radeon(tm) HD Graphics
Operating system: Linux 3.17.4-pclos1 64bit

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
SF 090115 MZ x64 vs. Shark 150111 x64 - 500R 15S+50ms

Code:

   Engine           Score            Sh         SF    S-B
1: Shark 150111 x64 286.0/500 ·········· 126-54-320  61204.
2: SF 090115 MZ x64 214.0/500 54-126-320 ··········  61204.

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
@drj4759 wrote:
SF Marco 150103 vs. Stockfish 15010309, Beluga 150103, Shark 150103, Orka 150103 - 500R 15S+50ms

Code:

  # PLAYER                    :  RATING    POINTS  PLAYED    (%)
  1 Shark 150103 x64          :  26.77    291.0    500  58.2%
  2 Beluga 150103 x64        :  21.02    287.0    500  57.4%
  3 Orka 150103 x64          :  19.59    286.0    500  57.2%
  4 SF Marco 150103 x64      :  -31.24    889.5    2000  44.5%
  5 Stockfish 15010309 x64    :  -36.14    246.5    500  49.3%



I guess I am puzzled. On one hand we are told

These useless monkeyfied Stockfish clones are just experimental compilation and should not be taken seriously. They are nothing to be excited about because Stockfish originals beats them all the time.

yet Shark Orca and Beluga come out ahead of their original here and in other results

.

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
@Tomfl wrote:
@drj4759 wrote:
SF Marco 150103 vs. Stockfish 15010309, Beluga 150103, Shark 150103, Orka 150103 - 500R 15S+50ms

Code:

   # PLAYER                    :  RATING    POINTS  PLAYED    (%)
   1 Shark 150103 x64          :   26.77     291.0     500   58.2%
   2 Beluga 150103 x64         :   21.02     287.0     500   57.4%
   3 Orka 150103 x64           :   19.59     286.0     500   57.2%
   4 SF Marco 150103 x64       :  -31.24     889.5    2000   44.5%
   5 Stockfish 15010309 x64    :  -36.14     246.5     500   49.3%



I guess I am puzzled. On one hand we are told

These useless monkeyfied Stockfish clones are just experimental compilation and should not be taken seriously. They are nothing to be excited about because Stockfish originals beats them all the time.

yet Shark Orca and Beluga come out ahead of their original here and in other results

.

They are all from the same original source code... In my opinion, Marco Costalba's stockfish is all you need.

descriptionStockfish and Clones Matches - Page 2 EmptyRe: Stockfish and Clones Matches

more_horiz
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum